Skip to content
Urban Luck Lab explores the intersection of chance and urba…

If the Blacksmith Has a Million Haters, Then I Am One of Them.

Upon learning the news about Clint in Stardew Valley was revealed as a new bachelors in the forthcoming version 1.7, I yelled incredulously, “That incel?!” I was fixated for hours afterward — if Clint has a legion of critics (and he does), count me among their ranks; if he has zero enemies, I have left this earthly realm. Yet, with some reflection, I’ve come to see that perhaps that’s exactly the point — there is no character in greater need of redemption than Clint.

The Root of the Dislike

Clint has attracted significant criticism over the years, primarily because of his obsession with Emily, another marriage candidate. During his first heart events, he seeks your advice about how to talk to women, proceeds to act with painful awkwardness around Emily, as she serves him in the saloon, only to moan to the player that he’s “doomed.” He frequently comes off as defeatist, needy, and borderline creepy — to many, he embodies a classic “nice guy” who gets angry at the smallest hint of rejection.

A Widespread Response

My reaction to this part of the new update was anything but solitary. There have been a myriad of complaints, disappointment over other characters who could have been picked instead, and endless jokes following the announcement. A commentator wrote, “Picture finishing the worst shift at work and learning Clint is now someone you can marry in Stardew Valley.”

A Glimmer of Potential

Nevertheless, some discussion about this offers a brighter perspective and — reluctantly — makes a few good points. Several players have compared the prospect of reforming Clint to that of Haley. Haley starts as extremely mean when you first meet her, but softens over time through friendship, a process some have referred to as “improving Haley to make her better as a person.” Clint possesses much that identical capacity, but with a crucial distinction: he gives a lot of players feel uncomfortable.

Screenshot: ConcernedApe

The Uneasy Feeling

I’ve personally always found Haley’s early rudeness more palatable than Clint’s one-sided obsession with a woman who isn't interested, and many other players seem to feel the same. It's difficult to pinpoint a finger on precisely why — perhaps it’s just a situation many fans can relate to, giving them a stronger gut response to Clint. This discomfort Clint possesses certainly adds an extra wrinkle in him being seen as an desirable romantic partner, but that’s arguably just another reason the character is in dire need of a turnaround.

A Trace of Understanding

It must be said that, as many times as I’ve complained about how much Clint needs to stop being weird, he does inspire some level of sympathy. Maybe not during the infamous bush-hiding incident, but in general, he comes across as a melancholy, isolated man. As one observer noted, “Clint is someone looking for someone who will choose him back, and this is what this candidacy offers him.”

A Place for Redemption

Clint’s new romance path may not be for every kind of Stardew Valley player, but it serves a purpose. However skeptical I am about ever consider him as spouse material, ConcernedApe is a skilled storyteller known for adding layers to every character in Pelican Town. Similar to previous expansions, the 1.7 update seems to be a sizable new addition crafted with care at its heart, and Clint’s development is unlikely to be being done flippantly. Maybe through this new romance future, players can at last put their hate for Clint and redirect it to its rightful target — toward Pierre.

EO
The writer

Erica Oconnell

Elara Vance is a cultural geographer and writer fascinated by patterns of chance in urban environments.

Urban Luck Lab

Type to search articles.